Skip to content Skip to navigation
The University of Massachusetts Amherst
  • Visit
  • Apply
  • Give
  • Search UMass.edu
Center for Agriculture, Food, and the Environment
UMass Extension Vegetable Program
Ask UMass Extension
  • Vegetable Home
  • About
    • About the Vegetable Program
    • Faculty & Staff
    • Funding
    • Request a visit
    • Request a Crop & Pest Management Planning Meeting
    • Contact us
  • Publications
    • Vegetable Notes
    • New England Vegetable Management Guide
    • Northeast Vegetable and Strawberry Pest Identification Guide
    • Cucurbit Disease Scouting & Management Guide
    • Sweet Corn IPM Scouting Guide & Record Keeping Book
    • Nutrient Management Guide for New England Vegetable Production
  • Fact Sheets
    • All Fact Sheets
    • Business Management
    • Cultural Practices
    • Diseases
    • Insect & Mite Pest
    • Soil & Nutrient Management
    • Vegetable Crops
    • Weeds
    • Wildlife Management
  • Special Topics
    • Brassica Pest Collaborative
    • Heating Greenhouses with Locally Grown Corn
    • Winter Production and Storage
  • Resources
    • Food Safety for Farmers
    • Nutrient Management
    • Scouting Resources
    • Research Reports
    • Recursos en Español (Spanish-Language Resources)
    • Useful Links
  • Services
    • Disease Diagnostics
    • Soil and Plant Nutrient Testing
    • UMass Extension Bookstore
    • Hot Water Seed Treatment
    • Mentor Farm Program
    • Scouting Program
  • News & Events
    • Upcoming Events
    • News
    • Past Events
  • Make a Gift

Evaluation of Alternative Insecticides to Control Cabbage Aphids in Cabbage, 2017

2017

Methods

Cabbage (‘Capture’) was seeded on June 7 and transplanted on July 8 at 18” in-row spacing in rows on 6’ centers. Treatment plots were 20’ in length and a randomized complete blocks design with 4 replications was used. Once the first aphids were observed, treatments were applied once a mean of ≥ 10 aphids/plant was reached using a pressurized backpack sprayer equipped with on hollow cone nozzle delivering 90 gallons per acre and operating at 60 psi. We counted aphids and mummies weekly and will collect marketable yield as well.

Table 1. Reduction in number of aphids after spraying shows relative efficacy of products tested
  28-Aug 4-Sep  
Product # Aphids # Aphids % Reduction
Untreated 10.7 5.1 52.3
Wrangler 9.8 0.95 90.3
Suffoil-X 6.3 5.5 12.7
M-Pede 8.7 3.75 56.9
Pyganic 5.0 13.3 5.3 60.0
Azatin O 8.1 5.6 31.1
Grandevo WDG 10.1 8.9 12.1
Mycotrol O 7.9 7.8 0.6
PFR97 8.2 10.85 -31.9
Parasitism Rate (%) 12.1 21.7  

Conclusions

Of the OMRI-approved insecticides tested the insecticidal soap M-Pede and the azadiractin-based product Azatin O significantly reduced the number of cabbage aphids per plant on three dates while other products did not significantly reduce CA numbers (see Figures 1 and 2 next page). Mixtures or rotations of these two products may be even more effective than either one used alone.

Image
Graph showing # of aphids over the course of the season
Image
Graph showing aphids per plant in the more effective treatments.

Ways to Connect

  • Ask a question
  • Request a Visit
  • Request a Crop & Pest Management Planning Session
  • Submit a Sample
  • Become a Mentor Farm
  • Join the NEVBGA
  • Make a Donation

Connect with us on Social Media

extension vegetable program facebook page  extension vegetable program instagram   extension vegetable program youtube channel

Center for Agriculture, Food, and the Environment

 

Stockbridge Hall,
80 Campus Center Way
University of Massachusetts Amherst
Amherst, MA 01003-9246
Phone: (413) 545-4800
Fax: (413) 545-6555
ag [at] cns [dot] umass [dot] edu (ag[at]cns[dot]umass[dot]edu)

 

Civil Rights and Non-Discrimination Information

College of Natural Sciences

Login for faculty and staff

CAFE Units

Mass. Agricultural Experiment Station

UMass Extension

UMass Research and Education Center Farms

UMass Cranberry Station

Water Resources Research Center

Gloucester Marine Station

Interest Areas

Agriculture

Commercial Horticulture

Energy

Environmental Conservation

Food Science

Nutrition

Water

Youth Development & 4-H

Projects

Conservation Assessment Prioritization System (CAPS)

Climate Action Tool

Mass. Keystone

MassWoods

North American Aquatic Connectivity Collaborative

RiverSmart

Services

Pesticide Education

Plant Diagnostics Laboratory

Soil and Plant Nutrient Testing Laboratory

Hot Water Seed Treatment

Water Testing / Environmental Analysis Laboratory

Resources

Extension Sales Portal

Agriculture & Commercial Horticulture Resources

Community & Economic Vitality

Disaster Preparedness

Food Safety

Home Lawn & Garden

Integrated Pest Management (IPM)

Land Conservation Tools

Pollinators

Tick testing

Resources for Faculty and Staff

Extension Programs

4-H Youth Development

Agriculture

Crops, Dairy, Livestock and Equine

Fruit

Greenhouse Crops and Floriculture

Landscape, Nursery and Urban Forestry

Pesticide Education

Turf

Vegetable

Clean Energy

Climate Change

Food Science

Nutrition Education

Value-Added Food

UMass collegiate M - University of Massachusetts Amherst
©2025 University of Massachusetts Amherst · Site Policies · Accessibility