Patricia Vittum, Natalia Clifton, and Kathleen Nowicki, Department of Entomology and UMass Extension Pesticide Education Program, University of Massachusetts.
William Coli and Craig Hollingsworth, Department of Entomology and UMass Extension Integrated Pest Management Program, University of Massachusetts.
Mark S. Buffone, Certification and Training Coordinator, Pesticide Program, Massachusetts Department of Agricultural Resources.
November 14, 2000, revised January 2014
Learning Objectives
- First read Chapter 13 in the Core Manual (3rd edition)
- Define the term Integrated Pest Management (IPM)
- Give reasons why you should practice IPM
- Describe the purpose of monitoring
- Define the terms assessment, action threshold, economic injury level, economic threshold and zero threshold
- Describe how forecasting is used to manage pests
- Be familiar with the different cultural control, physical control and mechanical strategies
- Describe how natural enemies can manage pests
- Define the three types of biological control: introduction, augmentation, and conservation
- Be familiar with the different chemical control options including reduced risk, biological, microbial, biochemical, and minimum risk pesticides
- Describe the roles that record keeping, communication and education can have in implementing an IPM program
- Be familiar with the terms found in the glossary section
Introduction
This supplemental publication was prepared to provide generic IPM information to those seeking to become a certified and/or licensed pesticide applicator in Massachusetts. This information addresses changes in the Massachusetts Pesticide Control Act (Chapter 132 B of the Massachusetts General Laws), which became effective on November 1, 2000. In particular, the changes require that “each examination shall include an evaluation of the applicant’s competence with respect to the use of Integrated Pest Management (IPM)”.
The goals of this publication are: to define Integrated Pest Management (IPM), to describe the benefits and essential elements of its use, to outline pertinent IPM examples in various settings and to provide an overall level of general knowledge necessary to implement IPM.
History
Since the advent of modern pest control chemicals in the 1940’s traditional methods of pest control typically involved periodic applications of pesticides whether or not pests were present and were in numbers sufficient to cause economic or other losses. This approach resulted in several problems, including: development of insect, disease and weed pest resistance to the chemicals used; outbreaks of previously minor pests; and environmental contamination. In addition, substantial concern arose about the possibility that pesticides could be causing adverse effects on public health.
Beginning in the 1950’s and continuing to the present day, University-based scientists and others began to develop a new approach to pest control, now known as Integrated Pest Management or IPM. Although IPM had its roots in agriculture crop protection for sites as diverse as apple orchards and sweet corn fields, IPM concepts and principles have now been applied to such non-agricultural settings as golf courses, schools, homes, and restaurants. Consequently, specific definitions of IPM vary greatly depending on which setting it is being applied to.
A Definition
This publication will use the definition cited in the Massachusetts Pesticide Control Act. Integrated Pest Management or IPM is a “comprehensive strategy of pest control whose major objective is to achieve desired levels of pest control in an environmentally responsible manner by combining multiple pest control measures to reduce the need for reliance on chemical pesticides; more specifically, a combination of pest controls which addresses conditions that support pests and may include, but is not limited to, the use of monitoring techniques to determine immediate and ongoing need for pest control, increased sanitation, physical barrier methods, the use of natural pest enemies and a judicious use of lowest risk pesticides when necessary.”
Practicing Integrated Pest Management or IPM
IPM can reduce the quantity of chemical pesticides entering the environment and can save money. IPM is based on taking preventive measures, monitoring pest problems, assessing pest numbers, and choosing appropriate actions. Corrective action, such as applying a pesticide, is only taken if pest numbers reach levels (action thresholds) which indicate that damage will occur. The action threshold for a pest and its associated damage may be different depending on the situation. For example, the damage may be economic in crop systems – will the damaged caused by the pest reduce the yield significantly? Damage may be based on aesthetics in landscapes – how many spider mites can be on a plant before the client notices and complains? Finally, pest “damage” may be related to public health issues – now that West Nile virus has been detected in Massachusetts, how much effort should go into controlling the mosquitoes that spread the disease? Many different tactics are used in IPM, including such things as cultural practices, biological control agents, physical and mechanical controls, and chemical pesticides.
The term integrated refers to the use of different tactics to avoid, minimize, and prevent a pest problem. These tactics are integrated into a system that improves the effectiveness of each method. IPM integrates information that comes from different disciplines, such as disease information from plant pathologists, weed information from weed scientists, and insect information from entomologists. For example, in a non-IPM spray program for apples, fungicides used to control apple scab might have a negative impact on the biological control agents of plant feeding mites. Similarly, in a non-IPM spray program for lawns, chinch bugs are control by insecticides that may have a negative impact on biological control by predators, such as big-eyed bugs. In an IPM system, the use of certain pesticides, that affect natural predators such as big-eyed bugs or predatory mites, would be avoided.
Pests are unwanted organisms that are a nuisance to people or domestic animals, and can cause injury to humans, animals, plants, structures, and possessions. Pests can include insects and other arthropods, plant diseases (including fungi, bacteria and viruses), vertebrates (such as rodents and birds), and weeds.
Management is the process of making decisions in a systematic way to keep pests from reaching unacceptable or intolerable levels. Small populations of pests often can be tolerated; total eradication often is not necessary or possible. However, there are settings in which the tolerance for a pest or its associated damage may be zero - for example, insects or vertebrates in a hospital. Proper management depends on information. In an IPM system, information is usually obtained from a regular and thorough site inspection called monitoring.
Why Practice IPM?
Why should you even consider IPM when chemical pesticides so often succeed at controlling pests? Here are some reasons for having a broader approach to pest management than just the use of chemicals.
Keep a Balanced Ecosystem
Every ecosystem, made up of living things and their non-living environment, has a balance; the actions of one creature in the ecosystem usually affect other organisms in that system. The introduction of chemicals into an ecosystem can upset this natural balance by destroying certain species and allowing others (sometimes pests themselves) to dominate. Beneficial insects and insect relatives such as the ladybird beetle (ladybug), lacewing larvae, tiny non-stinging wasps, or spiders, all of which consume pests, can be killed by pesticides; thereby, leaving few natural mechanisms of pest control. Pesticide use can sometimes lead to pest resurgence, whereby pests are initially controlled but later increase in numbers that then require additional pesticide applications. The use of pesticides can also lead to secondary pest outbreaks where the natural enemies of a species are destroyed allowing another pest whose population has been low historically to reach outbreak levels. For example, spraying carbaryl (Sevin™) for insects in orchards may kill mite predators, thereby leading to outbreaks of spider mites. Natural enemies can be destroyed in other settings as well. For example, spraying carbaryl (Sevin™) for insects on oak trees may kill natural enemies that help keep oak leaf skeletonizer in check, thereby leading to potentially damaging populations of that insect.
Pesticides Can Be Ineffective
Chemical pesticides sometimes are ineffective because pests can become resistant to their effects. Over 600 cases of pesticide resistance have been documented to date from all classes of pests; including, weeds such as common lamb’s-quarters, insects such as cockroaches, house fly, Colorado potato beetle, Indian meal moth, vertebrates such as Norway rat, and diseases such as apple scab. Furthermore, pests may survive because the chemical does not reach them, is washed off, is applied at an improper rate, or is applied at the wrong time during the life cycle.
IPM Is Not Difficult
Although some of the terms and ideas may be new to you, practicing IPM is not difficult. You will have done much of the “work” for an IPM approach if you have identified the pest, determined the source and cause of the problem, noted the extent of the damage, and used this information to decide on the action to take. Your action decision could include a chemical solution or a non-chemical one. This thinking process is the same one used in IPM.
IPM Is Cost Effective
IPM can save money by avoiding losses due to pests, and avoiding unnecessary pesticide expense whether in an agricultural or non-agricultural setting. For example, onion growers who followed IPM recommendations in 1987 saved more than $23 an acre in insecticide costs. Golf course superintendents who replace fungicides with organic fertilizers or composts can save up to $1500 every time a fungicide is not applied. Applicators are able to save on sprays because the calendar is not the basis for spraying; the need is.
In agricultural settings where pest pressure is high, pesticide reduction may or may not result, but IPM can provide a better quality crop. Connecticut sweet corn growers using IPM had less caterpillar damage after switching to an IPM program, and experienced an average increased profit of $227 per acre.
In non-agricultural settings such as buildings, IPM programs have resulted in lower costs than traditional pest control programs. For example, once non-chemical tactics such as repairing structural problems and sealing cracks are completed, a resulting reduction in pesticide use will usually result in lower costs. Over time, indoor IPM programs can become cost effective via the benefits such as improved work environments, reduced energy costs, and reduced building maintenance.
However, cost effectiveness is not based purely on the price of a gallon or pound of a pesticide. Even where pest pressure is high, an IPM program would consider using low-risk control tactics such as applying microbial pesticides for mosquito control. Although the use of a microbial pesticide may be more expensive than another pesticide, the result is less risk to humans and less impact and disruption to the environment.
Promote a Safer and Healthier Environment
We have much to learn about the persistence of chemicals both in the indoor and outdoor environment, and their effect on living creatures. For outdoors, more cases of contaminated groundwater and surface waters occur each year, and disposal of containers and unused pesticides still pose challenges for applicators. Even though long-term documentation of the effects of all pesticides is still unavailable, it is generally agreed that using fewer pesticides means that there will be less risk to surface water and groundwater, and less hazard to wildlife and humans. Indoors, building occupants may be exposed to chemical pesticides through the air or by direct contact with treated surfaces. Since the preventive aspects of IPM can result in fewer pests, they may also lead to less pesticide use. Fewer pesticides often mean lower exposure and/or risks to occupants from misapplications, spills, etc.
Maintain a Good Public Image
Public outcry about the presence of pesticide residues on produce has raised pesticide applicator awareness of the level of public concern about pesticides. Consumers are pressuring food stores, which in turn are pressuring growers, for produce that has been grown with as few pesticides as possible. Growing food, using integrated pest management, can help allay public concerns. Structural pest management professionals making recommendations for improvements in sanitation, clutter reduction, and/or structural modifications, minimize the need for chemical control and can also benefit by favorable public attitudes to their efforts.
Required by Certain Regulations
In response to concerns about pesticide use and potential overuse, many states have enacted regulations, which require the use of IPM in certain circumstances. Throughout the country, states are requiring schools to develop IPM plans and require IPM contracts with professional pest managers.
In Massachusetts, schools, day care centers, and school age child care programs are required to adopt and implement an Integrated Pest Management plan for both indoor (by November 1, 2001) and outdoor areas. Municipalities in many areas have specific contract requirements mandating IPM for town buildings and roads. In Massachusetts, state facilities can only use approved IPM contractors. In sensitive areas such as groundwater recharge zones, some pesticides may be limited to use only under an IPM plan. Also, IPM plans are required for vegetation management along roads, power lines and other rights-of-way.