The Impact of Eliminating Affirmative Action on Minority and Female Employment: A Natural Experiment Approach Using State-level Affirmative Action Ban Laws

Fidan Ana Kurtulus, Associate Professor, Department of Economics, University of Massachusetts Amherst
October 15, 11:30am to 1:00pm
WAPPP Cason Seminar Room, Taubman 102 Harvard Kennedy School

Fidan Ana Kurtulus, Associate Professor, Department of Economics, University of Massachusetts Amherst

Recent years have witnessed efforts to rescind affirmative action at the state-level, with California prohibiting affirmative action in public employment in 1996, Washington in 1998, Michigan in 2006, Nebraska in 2008, Arizona in 2010, and New Hampshire and Oklahoma in 2012, and the future of affirmative action at the federal-level in the United States is uncertain. This seminar examines the impact of eliminating affirmative action on the employment of minorities and women within a natural experiment framework using newly available state and local public employment data for 1990 to 2009 from the U.S. Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (EEO-4 files). The empirical analysis exploits the panel structure of the EEO-4 data, along with the time and state variation in affirmative action bans, to estimate difference-in-differences and dynamic event-study regressions of the effects of the bans on public sector employment. Key findings point to sharp declines in Hispanic male, black female, and Asian female representation following the law changes banning affirmative action, and in the case of black women, the declines become increasingly larger in magnitude over time.

Read more

In appreciation of their generous support, the UMass Public Engagement Project would like to thank the Office of the ProvostUniversity Relations, and the Colleges of Natural SciencesSocial and Behavioral Sciences Humanities and Fine ArtsEngineeringPublic Health and Health Sciences, and Education.  The UMass Public Engagement Project also recognizes and appreciates in-kind contributions and collaborations with the Center for Research on Families and the Institute for Social Science Research